Statement and Argument


Direction: In making decisions about important questions, it is desirable to be able to distinguish between ''Strong'' arguments and ''Weak'' arguments insofar as they relate to the question. ''Strong'' arguments are those which are both important and directly related to the question. ''Weak'' arguments are those which are of minor importance and also may not be directly related to the question or may be related to a trivial aspect of the question.

  1. Statement:
    Should TV channels is be allowed to telecast soft porn films?
    Arguments:
    I. Yes, it will help in satisfying youngsters' aphrodosiomania as a result of which cases related with woman 's molestation will reduce to some extent.
    II. No, it is against or tradition. Any such act will degrade our social value, especially for children, who use television as a medium of entertainment as well as education.











  1. View Hint View Answer Discuss in Forum

    The advantage shown in argument I is unlikely to be true and farfetched. But II is strong because we should not ignore our tradition.

    Correct Option: B

    The advantage shown in argument I is unlikely to be true and farfetched. But II is strong because we should not ignore our tradition.


  1. Statement:
    Should government hospitals charge user charges from those government employees who pay income taxes?
    Arguments:
    I. Yes. This will lessen the burden of the government and money thus accumulated will be helpful in providing more facilities to the needy .
    II. No. It will be an injustice towards those persons who pay income texes as a revenue to the country.











  1. View Hint View Answer Discuss in Forum

    I is strong , because it will make the financial position of hospital more strong and since user charges will be paid by the income-tax payer class, this user charge will put only a nominal burden on the budget of the class. II is a strong argument because the very reason why the state collects taxes is to provide physical and social infrastructure.

    Correct Option: E

    I is strong , because it will make the financial position of hospital more strong and since user charges will be paid by the income-tax payer class, this user charge will put only a nominal burden on the budget of the class. II is a strong argument because the very reason why the state collects taxes is to provide physical and social infrastructure.



  1. Statement:
    Should the habit of being absent from the class-room be checked in educational institutions?
    Arguments:
    I. Yes. Otherwise it will create a poor image of the institute in the society.
    II. No. This will be an act of encroaching upon one's liberty.











  1. View Hint View Answer Discuss in Forum

    Both I and II are weak argument. I portrays a trivial aspect, hence it is weak. II is weak because it advocates for one's liberty not in a rational sense.

    Correct Option: D

    Both I and II are weak argument. I portrays a trivial aspect, hence it is weak. II is weak because it advocates for one's liberty not in a rational sense.


  1. Statement:
    Should children be prevented completely form using the Internet?
    Arguments :
    I. No. Internet is a medium of education where children get education with entertainment.
    II. Yes. There are some sites available on Internet which show porno film or programmes etc, which affect the child's mind to a great extent; recent surveys have revealed most of the users of these sites are children.











  1. View Hint View Answer Discuss in Forum

    I is strong because a good medium of education thought entertainment must not be banned. II is a weak argument because just because of a few sites it would be not wise to ban children completely form using the Internet.

    Correct Option: A

    I is strong because a good medium of education thought entertainment must not be banned. II is a weak argument because just because of a few sites it would be not wise to ban children completely form using the Internet.



  1. Statement:
    Should there be a ban on the persons providing services to more than one firm or organisation?
    Arguments:
    I. Yes. It will reduce the problem of unemployment to some extent.
    II. No. It will create a lot of frustration and large amount of dissatisfaction and disappointment among the skillful and intellectual classes.











  1. View Hint View Answer Discuss in Forum

    I is not the appropriate way to reduce unemployment. Hence, I is a weak argument. II is obviously strong; otherwise the intellectual classes will feel humiliated and it will hamper the progress of the nation in the long run.

    Correct Option: B

    I is not the appropriate way to reduce unemployment. Hence, I is a weak argument. II is obviously strong; otherwise the intellectual classes will feel humiliated and it will hamper the progress of the nation in the long run.